Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robyn Ryle's avatar

You know I have a lot to say about this, Betsy. I currently live in a town with a population of 12,208. I believe that qualifies as small. I grew up in a town that at the time probably had a population of about 7,000. I think when you get above about 30,000, you're moving out of small town territory. I also think it's contextual. The "small town" I grew up in was in the middle of a rapidly growing area that was becoming suburban. So pretty quickly, it was no longer a small town, regardless of what the Census numbers said. Small town is as much a cultural phenomenon as it is numerical.

I've spent most of my life in rural areas. In Kentucky. Now in Indiana. My small town is plopped down in the middle of a very rural area. The biggest city is an hour away.

What do I think of when I think of small towns in rural areas? I know that these places tend to skew older as far as their population, though that may be changing a little bit. I don't think of them as more conservative. All kinds of people live in all kinds of places. The idea of "blue dots" or "red states" is sort of a myth we're telling ourselves. On the ground, it's all so much more complicated than that.

When I think of small towns in rural areas I think about quirkiness. I guarantee you that every small town has its collection of "weirdos," though they probably won't tell you about them because those "weirdos" aren't really weird to them. They're just their neighbors. They're just Frank down the street.

I think of people who are often living in ways that are more deeply connected. You're stuck with who you have, so you make things work. I think there's something really valuable there.

When I think of small towns, I think of the joy of being known in a way that's hard to get in other places. I walk down my streets and say hello to people. We stop and talk. They ask me about my writing and about my book. They ask how our trip was. I feel held, and yeah, cared for in small towns in a way I've never felt anywhere else.

I have a lot of opinions, including that for most of our human evolution, we lived in small groups and that maybe we're still better suited to a smaller scale. It's so much harder to generalize and de-humanize in smaller groups.

I like to think of myself as a chronicler of small towns. There are so many stories to tell. As Niall Williams said in THIS IS HAPPINESS: “A hundred books could not capture a single village. That’s not a denigration, that’s a testament.”

Expand full comment
Jennifer Silva Redmond's avatar

I lived in the town of O'Brien, Oregon, for almost a year as a kid. It couldn't have had more than a few hundred people. The only (tiny) store was also the post office. I was from Los Angeles so the town felt very small to me. I'd say that a town has to have less than ten thousand people. I have lived in rural towns and even on a small commune near Santa Cruz, CA. When I think of small American towns I think of main streets and town squares, and of community and cooperation. People helping each other out.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts